In England, a billionaire or a sovereign wealth fund can buy a football club outright. In Germany, that is generally not possible. The reason is a rule known as 50+1, and it is one of the most important and most debated regulations in European football.
Here is what the rule says, why it exists, which clubs are treated differently, and why Germany’s competition regulator has been examining it.
What the rule says
The 50+1 rule applies to clubs in the Bundesliga and 2. Bundesliga, governed by the German Football League (DFL). In simple terms, it says the parent club, which is a members’ association, must keep the majority of voting rights in the company that runs its professional team.
Many German clubs have moved their professional football operations into separate companies so they can raise money from investors. The 50+1 rule allows that, but only up to a point. Investors can own shares and put money in, but the members’ club must hold at least 50% of the votes plus one. That is where the name comes from.
The effect is that outside investors cannot take control of a club’s decisions, even if they own a large share of its finances.
Why it exists
The rule reflects a German idea of what a football club is. Most German clubs began as members’ associations, and many still have tens of thousands of members who vote on how the club is run. The 50+1 rule protects that structure.
Supporters see it as the reason German football has kept affordable ticket prices, large standing areas and a culture that puts fans at the centre. Critics argue it makes Bundesliga clubs less competitive financially than their English rivals, because investors are reluctant to put large sums into clubs they cannot control.
Both arguments have some truth in them. Bayern Munich have shown that a members-run club can be one of the richest in the world. But other German clubs have found it harder to compete with the spending power of the Premier League.
The exceptions
The rule has never been applied identically to every club, and that is where the controversy begins.
Under a provision known as the benefactor exemption, a company or individual that had supported a club substantially for more than 20 years could be allowed to take control. Two clubs currently benefit from this. Bayer Leverkusen has historically been owned by the pharmaceutical company Bayer, and VfL Wolfsburg by the carmaker Volkswagen.
TSG Hoffenheim used to be the third exception, through the long-term support of software billionaire Dietmar Hopp. But according to Germany’s competition regulator, the Bundeskartellamt, Hoffenheim is no longer covered by the exemption, after Hopp handed his majority voting rights back to the parent club in 2023.
Then there is RB Leipzig, which is not formally an exception at all. Leipzig complies with the letter of the rule, but its membership has historically been very small and closely tied to the club’s sponsor. Critics argue that this keeps the form of 50+1 while ignoring its spirit.
The competition regulator steps in
Because the 50+1 rule restricts who can invest in clubs, there has long been a question over whether it breaks competition law. The DFL asked the Bundeskartellamt to give a formal view on the issue.
In June 2025, the regulator published a preliminary assessment. Its key conclusions were:
- The basic rule is acceptable. The goal of keeping clubs member-led and giving fans a say is capable of justifying an exemption from competition law.
- It must be applied consistently. The regulator said all Bundesliga and 2. Bundesliga clubs must give fans genuine access to full voting membership. This was widely seen as a reference to clubs where membership is restricted.
- The DFL’s own voting must respect the rule. The regulator criticised how the DFL handled a vote in December 2023 on bringing an investor into its media rights business, specifically regarding how Hannover 96’s vote was cast.
- The exemptions cannot last forever. In light of recent European Court of Justice rulings, the regulator said it no longer seemed possible to protect clubs with benefactor exemptions in the long term. Eventually, all clubs will need to be controlled by a parent club that is open to new members.
That last point is the most significant. It suggests that, over time, Leverkusen and Wolfsburg may need to change their structures. The regulator acknowledged that a long transition period might be reasonable given what is at stake, and said it would finalise its recommendations after hearing from the DFL, the clubs and investors involved.
Why this matters for fans
For supporters in Germany, the regulator’s view was broadly good news. It confirmed that the core principle of fan control is legally sound, and it pushed for the rule to be applied more fairly.
For investors, the message was less encouraging. The door to taking over German clubs is not opening. If anything, it is closing further for clubs that have enjoyed special treatment.
Our view
The 50+1 rule is not perfect. It has been applied unevenly, and it does limit how much money German clubs can raise. But it has also given German football something that has largely disappeared in England: the sense that a club belongs to its supporters.
The rule’s critics often point to the Premier League’s wealth as proof that German football has got it wrong. We see it differently. The Bundesliga has made a choice to put fan ownership ahead of maximum revenue. Given what has happened to some clubs elsewhere under owners with no connection to the community, that choice looks more defensible every year.
The real test will be how the DFL responds to the regulator, and whether it can make the rule consistent without losing what makes it valuable.
Sources: Bundeskartellamt press release, June 2025, DW explainer, BBC Sport explainer.