Skip to content
The Football Desk
A packed World Cup stadium in North America

Did the 48-team World Cup work? A verdict four months on

6 min read

When FIFA expanded the World Cup from 32 to 48 teams, the objections were easy to predict. Too many weak sides. Too many dead rubbers. Too many games. The 2026 tournament in the United States, Canada and Mexico was the first test of all that, with 104 matches instead of 64.

Now that the dust has settled, it is possible to give a fairer verdict than the one most of us were ready to write before a ball was kicked. The short version: the format worked better than critics feared in some ways, and worse in others. Here is our assessment.

How the format worked

The 48 teams were split into 12 groups of four. The top two in each group went through, along with the eight best third-placed teams, creating a round of 32 before the familiar round of 16. One quirk that caught some people out: head-to-head record was used as the first tiebreaker in the groups, ahead of overall goal difference.

The BBC’s post-tournament analysis of the format is the best single summary of how it played out, and we draw on its figures throughout this piece.

The case for: goals, crowds and new stories

More goals. The group stage averaged 2.99 goals per game, the highest since 1998. Whatever else the format did, it did not produce a tournament of cagey stalemates.

Record attendance. FIFA reported a total attendance of 6,810,966, a record for a World Cup. That number is boosted by the extra games, of course, but it still shows the demand was there.

Underdogs who belonged. The best story of the group stage was Cape Verde. On their World Cup debut, they drew 0-0 with eventual champions Spain, drew 2-2 with Uruguay and finished second in their group. They then lost only 3-2 to Argentina in the round of 32. Their goalkeeper, Vozinha, was 40 years old. Under the old format, Cape Verde almost certainly would not have qualified at all.

Curaçao, meanwhile, became the smallest nation ever to reach a men’s World Cup. And Africa had its strongest tournament in terms of progression: nine of its ten teams reached the last 32.

Those stories are the whole point of expansion. FIFA’s argument was that more countries deserved a seat at the table, and several of them proved it.

The case against: mismatches and maths

More one-sided games. The BBC counted 18 group games won by three goals or more, compared with five in Qatar in 2022. That is a big jump, and some of those matches were uncomfortable to watch. Expansion inevitably brings in teams whose squads are far below the level of the top nations.

Not every confederation benefited. Asia had a difficult tournament, taking 0.67 points per game, with only Australia and Japan reaching the knockout rounds. That raises a fair question about whether the extra Asian places were the right allocation, or whether they simply exposed a gap.

The third-place problem. This was the format’s biggest flaw. With eight of the twelve third-placed teams going through, final group games became an exercise in maths. Four teams had won their groups with a game to spare, and five were eliminated before their final match.

The worst example came on the final group matchday. Austria and Algeria drew 3-3, a result that eliminated Iran, while Australia and Paraguay played out a 0-0. Neither game was fixed, and nobody should suggest otherwise. But when teams know before kick-off exactly which result suits both sides, the spectacle suffers. Veteran coach Carlos Queiroz called the format “vulgar and ordinary”, as quoted by the BBC. That is strong language, but it captured a real frustration.

What the knockout rounds proved

Once the round of 32 began, the tournament was outstanding. Argentina had to come through Cape Verde, Egypt and England. Spain beat Austria, Portugal, Belgium and France. England and France then played out a 6-4 third-place match that was one of the most entertaining games of the summer.

The quality of the later rounds is a reminder that expansion did not dilute the very top of the tournament. The best teams still reached the end. What expansion changed was the first two weeks.

Our verdict

The 48-team World Cup worked as a celebration and as a business. It was a more mixed success as a sporting competition.

Where it succeeded, it did so because of the new teams. Cape Verde, Curaçao and the strength of the African contingent gave the tournament a breadth it has never had before. Where it failed, it failed because of the third-place system, which made too many final group games about permutations.

What FIFA should change

If FIFA is serious about protecting the integrity of the group stage, there is one obvious option: groups of three, with only the top two going through. FIFA originally planned that format and then dropped it over worries about collusion in the final round of games. The irony is that the 2026 format produced exactly that kind of situation anyway.

An alternative would be to keep groups of four but drop the third-place qualifiers, which would mean a different knockout bracket. Neither option is perfect. But a format where the most-discussed final group game is a 3-3 draw that suited both teams has a problem that needs fixing before 2030.

For all that, the core idea behind expansion — giving more of the world a chance to play at the World Cup — was justified on the pitch. That should not get lost in the arguments about the format.

Sources: BBC Sport format analysis, The Guardian, FIFA, BBC Sport awards round-up.

More from The Football Desk