Skip to content
The Football Desk
Referee making the VAR review signal

VAR explained: what it can review, what it can't, and what changed in 2026

6 min read

Video assistant referees have been part of top-level football for years now, and they still divide opinion more than almost anything else in the game. Some fans see VAR as a necessary correction for obvious mistakes. Others think it has drained spontaneity from goal celebrations and created new controversies.

Whatever your view, it helps to understand what VAR is actually allowed to do. The rules are set out in the VAR protocol, published by the International Football Association Board (IFAB), and they were expanded for the 2026/27 season.

The basic principle

The single most important phrase in the VAR protocol is “clear and obvious error”. VAR is not supposed to re-referee the game. It is supposed to step in only when the on-field decision was clearly wrong, or when a serious incident was missed entirely.

IFAB’s principles also make a few other things clear:

What VAR can review

Under the updated protocol, VAR can only be involved in a limited number of categories of decision:

  1. Goal or no goal, including any attacking offence in the build-up (a foul, handball or offside), whether the ball went out of play first, and offences at penalty kicks.
  2. Penalty or no penalty, including whether the offence happened inside or outside the area.
  3. Red cards: direct red cards (such as serious foul play, violent conduct or denying an obvious goal-scoring opportunity) and, since 2026, clearly incorrect second yellow cards.
  4. Mistaken identity, when the referee cautions or sends off the wrong player.
  5. Clearly incorrectly awarded corner kicks, but only if the decision can be changed immediately without delaying the restart, and only in competitions that choose to use this option.

Everything else, including ordinary yellow cards, free kicks in midfield and throw-ins, is outside VAR’s remit.

What changed for 2026/27

IFAB approved several changes at its annual general meeting in February 2026, in time for the World Cup. According to the BBC, the main VAR changes were:

Second yellow cards. VAR can now intervene when a second yellow card, and so a sending-off, was clearly wrongly given. The BBC cited a high-profile example from February 2026, when Juventus defender Pierre Kalulu was sent off for a second booking against Inter in a decision Serie A’s refereeing chief later described as “clearly wrong”. The BBC also reported that the Premier League’s Key Match Incidents Panel had found 17 players wrongly sent off for two cautions over the previous two seasons.

Importantly, VAR cannot recommend a second yellow that the referee missed. The BBC reported that IFAB felt this would be too intrusive, opening a possible review for every challenge by a player already on a booking.

Wrong-team bookings. VAR can now correct a yellow card given to the wrong team, for example when a defender is booked for handball but the ball actually struck an attacker’s arm.

Corners. VAR can check whether a corner was wrongly awarded, but only if it can be done immediately. This was strongly pushed by FIFA, and the BBC reported that leagues can opt in. The Premier League was not expected to adopt it, while Serie A was considered likely to.

How a review works

When the VAR spots a possible clear and obvious error, the process works like this:

  1. The VAR “checks” the footage, often without the players knowing. Most checks are silent and end with the original decision standing.
  2. If the VAR thinks there may be a clear error, they tell the referee.
  3. The referee decides whether to review. For factual decisions, such as offside or whether a foul was inside the box, the referee usually accepts the VAR’s information directly.
  4. For subjective decisions, such as how serious a foul was or whether a handball was an offence, the referee normally goes to the pitchside monitor for an on-field review.
  5. The referee makes the TV signal and gives the final decision.

There is one important limit. Once play has restarted after an incident, it generally cannot be reviewed, except in cases of mistaken identity or serious misconduct such as violent conduct or spitting.

Why VAR still causes arguments

The biggest problem with VAR is not the technology but the threshold. “Clear and obvious” means different things to different officials, and decisions on subjective incidents like handball often depend on interpretation. When one referee overturns a decision and another lets a similar one stand, fans understandably lose trust.

The other problem is time. Reviews can be slow, and the delays disrupt the flow of matches and celebrations in the stadium. That is why the push for faster tools, like semi-automated offside, has been so strong.

Our view

VAR has made football more accurate on the decisions it covers. Fewer goals are given for clear offsides, and fewer players are sent off for challenges they never made. The 2026 changes are sensible: the second-yellow rule fixes an obvious gap in the system, and the corner checks only apply when they cause no delay.

But VAR will never end the arguments, because football is full of subjective decisions. The best we can hope for is a system that catches the obvious mistakes quickly and leaves the rest to the referee on the pitch. The new protocol moves a step closer to that.

Sources: IFAB VAR protocol, BBC Sport on 2026 law changes.

More from The Football Desk